Repatriation of sacred indigenous cultural heritage and the law – Lessons from the United States and Canada

The thesis focusses on sacred cultural heritage that was taken from indigenous communities during colonialism and remains in museum collections both in Europe and abroad. Such heritage has been the frequent subject of claims by indigenous communities who seek the return of the heritage that was taken in the past.

Tünsmeyer examines how the legal aspects of such returns can be structured and which elements need to be taken into account to align these returns with contemporary human rights law. Both in Canada and in the United States laws have been passed that affect or even regulate such returns. The central question of the research therefore considers how future returns, including those from European collections, could be structured to reflect both the lessons learned in the US and Canada and current human rights standards.

The dissertation offers guidelines and models to help museums and policymakers in the drafting of laws or policies that structure return mechanisms. 

Also read

  • Valentina Golunova was awarded the Special Distinction for her PhD thesis “Silenced by Default: Algorithmic Content Moderation and Freedom of Expression in the European Union” by the European Group of Public Law (EGPL)

  • Intercountry adoption often appears to be the ultimate humanitarian deed. However, the reality is more complex. Dr. Elvira Loibl, assistant professor at the Department of Criminal Law at Maastricht University’s Law Faculty, uncovered significant weaknesses in the Dutch intercountry adoption system. ...

  • Paula Roldán Barraza will join METRO as a PhD researcher. She will be based both at SBE and at LAW and will be supervised by Iwan Bos (SBE), Niels Philipsen (METRO) and Kalpana Tyagi (IGIR).