What can legal logic and social ontology teach us about international cooperation?

On 18 March 2021, Henrique Marcos, Dr Antonia Waltermann, and Prof Dr Jaap Hage (Foundations and Methods of Law, Faculty of Law, UM) presented their paper "From Sovereignty to International Cooperation: Lessons from Legal Logic and Social Ontology" at the 10th Annual Cambridge International Law Conference.

Their presentation showed how theoretical tools from legal logic could help us find a coherent legal system in a pluralistic and fragmented collection of sources of international law. Marcos, Waltermann and Hage argued that — due to the specific nature of legal rules and the logic that applies to them — the proliferation of international rules and fragmentation of international law, as brought about by exercises of sovereignty, does not necessarily lead to rule conflicts or inconsistencies. What is needed is a framework of (meta)rules, logic for rules, and information about the relations between rules that can turn the unsupervised set of international rules into a consistent and workable set.

Their panel, "Co-operative Frameworks in International Law: Theory and Practice", was shared with presentations made by Ms Sandrine Brachotte (PhD Candidate, Sciences Po Paris, Frances), Dr Marek Jan Wasinski (University of Lodz, Poland), and Dr Ayako Kobayashi (Sophia University, Tokyo).

 

Also read

  • Valentina Golunova was awarded the Special Distinction for her PhD thesis “Silenced by Default: Algorithmic Content Moderation and Freedom of Expression in the European Union” by the European Group of Public Law (EGPL)

  • Intercountry adoption often appears to be the ultimate humanitarian deed. However, the reality is more complex. Dr. Elvira Loibl, assistant professor at the Department of Criminal Law at Maastricht University’s Law Faculty, uncovered significant weaknesses in the Dutch intercountry adoption system. ...

  • Paula Roldán Barraza will join METRO as a PhD researcher. She will be based both at SBE and at LAW and will be supervised by Iwan Bos (SBE), Niels Philipsen (METRO) and Kalpana Tyagi (IGIR).