Globalisation & Law Network seminar with Elies van Sliedregt
On 8 May 2024, the Globalisation & Law Network hosted a seminar featuring Elies van Sliedregt, Professor of Criminal Law and Procedure at Tilburg University. Her talk, based on the inaugural lecture ‘Uitzonderlijk strafrecht’ (‘Exceptional Criminal Law’) delivered on 31 March 2023, delved into the relationship between international criminal law and international refugee law.
Professor van Sliedregt discussed the prosecution of foreign nationals for international crimes committed outside the forum state, emphasising the role played by the International Criminal Court (ICC). She highlighted the concept of universal jurisdiction, which permits states to prosecute individuals for serious international crimes regardless of the location of the crime or the nationality of the perpetrator. Despite the apparent narrowing of this practice in countries such as Spain and Belgium, Professor van Sliedregt pointed out that data indicates an overall increase in the application of universal jurisdiction. France's recent efforts to charge companies complicit in human rights violations serve as a notable example of this trend. The presentation then focused on the practice of countries such as Germany, Sweden, and Norway that have adopted pure universal jurisdiction for war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide. Professor van Sliedregt also examined the challenges of the application of Article 1F(a) of the 1951 Refugee Convention, which excludes individuals from refugee status if there are serious reasons for considering that they have committed certain serious crimes.
Subsequently, Professor van Sliedregt explored the motivations behind prosecuting international crimes. She outlined two primary approaches, namely: the “Global Enforcement” approach (exemplified by Germany), and the “No Safe Haven” approach (an approach aimed at preventing impunity, which traces back to the historical efforts in Canada and the US to track down Nazi war criminals). The talk also touched on the selective nature of justice and the obstacles in prosecuting high-cost defendants versus low-cost ones.
Professor van Sliedregt’s presentation was followed by reflections offered by Alexandre Skander Galand.
If you are interested in the intersection of law and a more than ever globalised world, we invite you to join our upcoming seminars organised by the Globalisation & Law Network. Stay updated on our program and register here.
Also read
-
PhD thesis by Cécile Woudenberg-van den Broek
Recent reports on forensic medicine in the Netherlands highlight the need for significant improvements in postmortem investigations. This thesis questions the adequacy of the Dutch system, arguing that it may not meet the criteria set by the European Convention on Human Rights for an effective postmortem investigation. -
Intercountry adoption often appears to be the ultimate humanitarian deed. However, the reality is more complex. Dr. Elvira Loibl, assistant professor at the Department of Criminal Law at Maastricht University’s Law Faculty, uncovered significant weaknesses in the Dutch intercountry adoption system. Her impactful research was awarded the annual Edmond Hustinx prize.
-
Paula Roldán Barraza will join METRO as a PhD researcher. She will be based both at SBE and at LAW and will be supervised by Iwan Bos (SBE), Niels Philipsen (METRO) and Kalpana Tyagi (IGIR).