Financial Instruments and their Proportionality and Consistency under EU Law
Not just since the corona crisis have financial instruments in the form of guarantees, loans, and equity witnessed a growing popularity as a form of state aid vis-à-vis ‘regular’ grants. This thesis investigated whether the European Commission designs financial instruments and applies their legal framework in accordance with the principles of proportionality and consistency under European Union (EU) law.
It found that the Commission does not adhere to the requirements of financial instruments under the case law of the EU Courts in a consistent manner. Specifically, it does not conduct the required balancing exercise of positive and negative effects of instruments, but applies maximum amounts and screening methods as well as a checklist in its compatibility assessment under the proportionality principle. Thus, the thesis recommends the introduction of so-called manifest negative effects, which are applied in other state aid areas and are apt to solve these inconsistencies: They would indicate to stakeholders which potential negative effects could disproportionally distort competition and markets and therefore be incompatible with EU law.
Click here for the full dissertation
Click here for the live stream
Also read
-
Globalisation & Law Network with Christine Frison and Adriana Moreno Cely
On 15 May 2025, the Globalisation & Law Network held a seminar featuring Prof.dr. Christine Frison and Dr Adriana Moreno Cely (University of Liège), who presented their forthcoming article ‘Navigating Chaos: Decolonial and Feminist Methodologies in International Biodiversity Law’ (co-authored with...
-
We are hiring, come work with us! the Faculty of Law is looking for an Assistant Professor in EU law
The Department of European Law of the Faculty of Law of Maastricht University is looking for an Assistant Professor in EU Law, starting 1 September 2025.
-
La Protection Juridique de la Faune et de la Flore en Afrique: cas de la Côte d’Ivoire et du Cameroun
PhD thesis by Serge Landy Gbélé