15 November 2022

Sorting through democracy’s arsenal

From polarisation, misinformation and populists at home to geopolitical pressure from abroad: European democracy is feeling the strain. In an effort to uphold and expand one of its core values, the EU is financing a research project on the promotion of democracy. Professor Giselle Bosse, an Eastern Europe expert at FASoS, leads the work package ‘Democratisation and economic modernisation in authoritarian and hybrid regimes.’

Giselle 1

Accommodating Russian sensibilities

Geopolitics also plays a significant role. “Russia’s interference in Ukraine’s fight for democracy is only one example. Armenia had prepared a trade agreement with the EU, only to pull out at the last minute after a visit from the Russian foreign minister.” After Russia’s 2014 war against Ukraine, the EU has been less ambitious in supporting countries like Georgia and Moldova on their path towards democratisation and reform.

Bosse points out that the eastward enlargement of the EU brought with it not only new members, but also new neighbours, such as Ukraine. “The EU wanted good relations and no hard borders. At the same time, there was a sense of enlargement fatigue, resulting in reluctance to give these countries the prospect of joining the EU eventually.” Instead they were to become the European ‘neighbourhood,’ which initially included Russia. But Russia rejected this idea, preferring to remain ‘strategic partners.’

The EU wanted good relations and no hard borders. At the same time, there was a sense of enlargement fatigue, resulting in reluctance to give these countries the prospect of joining the EU eventually.
Giselle Bosse

The Prematurian candidate?

Now the EU is offering Ukraine candidate status not only to boost democratic reform in the country, but also to make a political statement. “Ukraine isn’t suddenly ‘more ready’ to join the EU.” Even those countries that previously acceded to the EU fell short on the reform indicators set out in the EU’s Copenhagen criteria from 1993, Bosse says.

“Not even the Netherlands is implementing all of the rules and regulations—take the lagging food-safety standards due to the agricultural lobby.” EU membership is by no means a panacea for Poland’s legal issues, the situation in Hungary or corruption issues in general. “But there’s an overall trend towards the better. If you look at press freedom, Estonia and Lithuania are now ranked among the top in Europe; far ahead of the Netherlands.”

As an example, Croatia’s candidature lasted over 10 years, and it had the advantage of not being at war. “Candidates are not expected to fulfil all the membership criteria already. Under its association agreement, Ukraine already implemented many reforms, particularly in banking and public procurement. They still only score 3.2 out of 10 for corruption [10 being the least corrupt]—nothing to be proud of—but Poland was at 3.6 and Romania 3.1 the year before joining.”

Close to home

For her research, Bosse has visited Ukraine many times. “The Maidan, or independence square, where more than 100 people died fighting for democracy and freedom, left a strong impression on me.” The current Russian invasion has hit hard. “I recognise all the places in Kyiv they show on the news.”

Bosse speaks of friends and colleagues who are unable to leave the country because of conscription, who have relatives stuck in war zones, or whose relatives have been killed or reported missing. “Everyone has a story like that. I got to know many Ukrainians when we were students. Now there’s this massive rupture in their lives.”

What worries Bosse most is that ‘the West’ is gradually losing interest in the war. “International media coverage has gone down markedly in the past two months. Ukrainian flags are disappearing from windows and flagpoles, donations are decreasing. That makes a project like EMBRACE all the more important. We’re working together with scholars from Ukraine to analyse how the EU can best support the country’s reform efforts in the coming years, and to ensure that Ukraine and its people stay high on the agenda of EU policymakers.”


Text by Florian Raith
Photography by Sem Shayne