EDLunch: So, PBL survives GPT?

“What comes to mind when you think of ChatGPT in relation to (your) education?” asked Walter Jansen as he opened the EDLunch session at EDLAB last Monday. 

ChatGPT is here to stay, but PBL can handle it

The curious and eager audience of staff and students seemed well acquainted with the new AI language model chatbox and its capabilities. Their answers appeared in a digital word cloud with words like “challenge, risk, fraud and crisis”, but also “interesting, exciting, and let’s play with this.” A majority agreed that ChatGPT is here to stay.

Evolution or Revolution?
Walter pointed out that education has survived and developed alongside AI tools such as WolframAlpha (math exercises), GoogleMaps (topography), AIVA (composition), Stockfish (chess), Deepl (translation). “Is ChatGPT an evolution or a revolution?” he asked the audience. One teacher said this period reminded them of the introduction of the calculator. It raises the critical question, “Do you test other outcomes or remove the tool completely?”

Like people, ChatGPT is not without its flaws. It is helpful to consider this when devising methods to integrate AI into education. For instance, a lecturer may ask students to improve or analyse content produced by the chatbox. Maastricht University is developing rules and regulations regarding its use, but ultimately, the feeling in the room was that trust in the system and in students is key.

What makes us human?
Finally, Walter shared that he had quizzed the robot on a fairly existential question: “What makes us uniquely human?” The answer to this question will help us to determine how we can best move forward with the technology. Among other features, ChatGPT replied: “social interaction, cultural context and self-directed learning”. Don’t these sound like the guiding principles of UM’s PBL teaching philosophy? How eery that ChatGPT recognises these as defining differences between itself and us!

By Munshya Mupela, Student Assistant at EDLAB

Also read

  • The 2024 Turriano Prize from ICOHTEC (the International Committee for the History of Technology) was awarded to Jacob Ward’s book Visions of a Digital Nation (MIT Press, 2024). The Turriano Prize recognises the best first book by an historian of technology. 

  • The Grote Gracht is richly lined with historical buildings that conceal remarkable stories. Once again, our “hidden gem” is located on this street in Maastricht, this time at number 76: the (bike) cellar.

  • Since Hungary took over the rotating presidency of the EU Council on July 1st, its Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has embarked on a widely criticized peace mission for Ukraine, including meetings with leaders of Russia and China. This has led to much speculation about what the next six months of the...