Article by MCEL member Nozizwe Dube on EU equality law published in CMLRev 62(1)
The article examines the types of reasoning that the CJEU adopts in its judgements on equality law and their role in fostering a formal approach to equality or building inclusive equality.
Despite efforts to imbue equality law with substantive equality, remnants of the formal model of equality remain in equality law’s architecture. The requirement for claimants to compare themselves to a comparator in order to establish a prima facie case of discrimination exemplifies this attachment to formal equality. This article identifies the different types of comparison used by the CJEU in its equality jurisprudence: intercategorical comparison, intracategorical comparison, and comparator-free approaches. It is argued that intercategorical and intracategorical comparisons sustain the formal model of equality by encouraging a decontextualized analysis of disadvantage which leads to judgments that impose assimilation rather than foster the inclusion of minoritized groups. In order to advance towards inclusive equality - which acknowledges intersectionality - a deviation from comparison altogether is the desirable way forward for equality law. Ousting comparison from the centre of equality law makes it more agile to conduct its primary mandate: identify and dismantle (intersecting) systems of marginalization
Nozizwe Dube, ‘A Typology of Comparators and Comparisons in EU Equality Law’ (2025) 62 Common Market Law Review 49. Read the full paper here.

Also read
-
Professional growth the European way
Many former students have fond memories of time spent abroad during their degree, whether they spent a semester in Italy or went to Latvia for an internship. Stays abroad are possible for university staff as well, for example, as part of YUFE Staff Development Programmes.
-
Protests at Maastricht University 2025 - Update 1
This morning, pro-Palestinian demonstrators began a protest at the Faculty of Law. In doing so, they blocked the entrances to the faculty building. UM is speaking with the protesters. The UM approach is clear: we give space to demonstrations where we can, and at the same time we want to safeguard...
-
Limburg Immersive Technologies (LIT) network officially launched, connecting academia, industry, and society to shape the future of XR in the Euregion
Maastricht University and Zuyd University of Applied Sciences officially unveiled the Limburg Immersive Technologies (LIT) Network on 6 May 2025 at the Teaching Hotel Château Bethlehem in Maastricht. The launch gathered researchers, educators, innovators, industry leaders, students, and policymakers...