Encouraging labor market mobility among job seekers can be counterproductive
Many governments offer financial support to unemployed job seekers with the aim of increasing their willingness to look for work outside their local labor market. Research by Maastricht University shows that this sometimes does more harm than good. "Policies that encourage looking outside one's search area are overvalued. In the end, few seekers accept a job far outside their own region. It's actually a waste of time and money," said Steffen Künn, associate professor at Maastricht University's School of Business and Economics.
Mobility programs
Regional employment disparities are the cause of a wide range of policy interventions. By reducing workers' mobility costs, such policies can reduce geographic mismatch, offset adverse shocks to local labor demand, and thereby improve overall welfare. But despite this attractive prospect and the widespread use of such policies, until now there had been no scientific evidence of their intended effect.
Waste of time
"Indeed, our research shows that job seekers do indeed respond and start searching and applying for distant jobs," Künn said. "But what it also shows is that this ultimately leads to lower employment and income. This is because many unemployed job seekers never accept a remote job, and so the remote job search is somehow a waste of time that would be better invested in local search."
Other policies
So what should/could policymakers do to rectify this? "Policymakers should stop offering such programs to all unemployed job seekers. Instead, they should focus more on job seekers who are actually able to find work and willing to accept work in a distant region. In addition, policymakers could improve remote job search assistance, since the research shows that local employment agents at temp agencies seem to be limited in their ability to support job seekers seeking employment in a distant labor market," Künn concludes.
Also read
-
Read our latest interview with Stella Shukla, SBE-Alumna and now managing consultant in digital transformation, who shares how a mix of strategic thinking and hands-on experience has defined her path from student to consultant. Stella’s roles at Atos and KPMG laid a foundation in consulting, which she built on through transformative projects at Horváth, where she now navigates cutting-edge topics like Generative AI and Agile Transformations. Her advice for aspiring consultants focuses on gaining practical experience and keeping up with digital trends.
-
The Maastricht Business Days (MBD) have been a hallmark of the School of Business and Economics (SBE) since their inception in 1996, standing out as the most prestigious student recruitment event. Organized by SCOPE, the faculty’s dynamic study association, the MBDs connect over 600 students annually with approximately 50 leading companies from diverse industries. This student-led initiative not only encourages professional growth through workshops, interviews, and networking events but also highlights the collaborative spirit of SBE, uniting students, alumni, and industry professionals in meaningful ways.
-
In the face of societal challenges and changes in the labor market, lifelong development should be obvious for everyone. However, research by Maastricht University's Research Center for Education and the Labor Market (ROA) funded by the LLO-Katalysator shows that participation in work-related courses has been relatively stable since 2004, remaining at 53 percent.