Black Friday: a real bargain, or the autumn sale in a new coat?

In the Netherlands, Black Friday has grown into a month of deals. Yet what is presented as a once-a-year opportunity is largely a rebranded autumn sale, and our memory for prices is not good enough to tell the difference. Why do we fall for it, and what can we do about it?

Black Friday falls on 27 November this year, but you would be forgiven for thinking it has already started. Many shops now launch their Black Friday promotions weeks in advance, and some run them throughout November. Consumers follow suit. In 2024, for the first time since 2016, Black Friday was not the busiest day of the year for iDEAL payments; the Monday before it was. Black Friday itself remains a peak: last year, it saw about 6.3 million iDEAL transactions, against 5.8 million a year earlier.

So, is Black Friday the moment to buy? My answer is: sometimes, but far less often than advertising suggests. To see why, it helps to look at what Black Friday is, and at how we as consumers judge prices.

An old sale in a new coat

Black Friday is largely a rebranding of something retailers have always done: the autumn sale. The period from late October to late December, with Sinterklaas, Christmas and New Year, is the shopping season par excellence, generating about 30% of the yearly revenue for retailers. Given the importance of this period for revenue, fierce battles for consumers' wallets emerge. To draw in more customers in this important period, retailers offer discounts on some products, but certainly not on all of them. 

Nothing new so far. What has changed is the packaging. A single, internationally recognised label now bundles these offers into one event, and the sheer number of deals coming from all sides creates an environment in which consumers get the impression that there is something to gain everywhere.

That same environment puts pressure on retailers. When competitors in your sector start their promotions, you cannot afford to stay behind without losing customers, and once one store starts earlier, others follow. Pieter Zwart, CEO of Coolblue, for example laments this in a recent interview.

This is why Black Friday is turning into Black November. For most retailers, however, it is not a goldmine. Offers mainly arrive earlier in the season; they do not generate a lot of additional revenue. Black Friday is therefore primarily a rebalancing of sales that would otherwise have taken place in December. Online shops do gain one practical advantage: not every parcel has to be shipped in the hectic weeks before Christmas.

Why we cannot tell a good deal from an ordinary one

There are good deals to be found on Black Friday. However, many of them are also offered at other moments in the year. A 2025 investigation by British consumer organisation Which? illustrates this. It tracked the prices of 175 Black Friday deals on home, tech and health products over a full year, and found that 83% were the same price or cheaper at least once outside the sales period. None was at its cheapest on Black Friday itself. Economists have long observed the underlying pattern: retailers time their markdowns to the periods in which people shop most, such as weekends and the run-up to Christmas (Warner and Barsky, 1995). Seen this way, Black Friday is a peak in a recurring cycle of discounts rather than a unique opportunity.

Why, then, do so many of us believe we are getting a once-a-year bargain? The main reason is that we are poor at remembering prices. In a classic US study, fewer than half of supermarket shoppers could correctly state the price of a product they had just placed in their cart (Dickson and Sawyer, 1990). In a later study among 400 shoppers at a French hypermarket, only about one in six named a price within 5% of the actual store price (Vanhuele and Drèze, 2002). Shoppers do better when asked to recognise a price or spot a deal than when asked to recall one, but even then, these are products people buy every week. For a television, a coffee machine or a winter coat, which we buy only once every few years, our sense of what a normal price is will likely be even weaker.

Without a reliable benchmark in our heads, we rely on cues from our environment to decide whether to buy: the crossed-out "original" price, the red discount label, the countdown timer and the constant stream of Black Friday advertising. And because a discount is only temporary, we do not want to miss out. These cues are precisely what makes a deal feel good, regardless of whether it is.

Black Friday

Fake discounts: bad intent or bad bookkeeping?

The crossed-out price is also where things go wrong. Under European rules, a discount must be calculated from the lowest price the seller charged in the 30 days before the promotion. Yet when the Dutch Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) checked 24 large retailers in the run-up to Black Friday last year, three quarters of them did not comply with the rules on discounts (NOS, 2025).

In my view, this reflects a mix of two things. Some retailers deliberately try to get away with inflated reference prices, knowing that enforcement is difficult and can only be done through spot checks; a regulator simply cannot oversee every product in every shop. Yet not every violation reflects bad intent. For retailers with large assortments, keeping exact track of the price history of tens of thousands of products, whose prices may change several times a day, is genuinely difficult. For the consumer, of course, the result is the same: a discount that is smaller than it looks.

What you can do

Two simple steps go a long way. First, do not rely on the price the shop shows you. Price comparison websites often show how the price of a product has developed over the past months, which tells you whether a Black Friday price is genuinely low or simply the price it was in September. Second, and perhaps more importantly, ask yourself whether you really need the product. A 30% discount on something you would not otherwise have bought is not a saving.

Black Friday is not going away, and for retailers who feel the pressure of their competitors it is hard to opt out. As consumers, however, we can choose how much weight we give to the cues around us. The best deal of the year may well be on Black Friday. But it may just as well be on an ordinary Tuesday in March.

Author:
Niels Holtrop